The Starlane Method™
The rules every Starlane Report lives by. Where the numbers come from, how they get checked, and why you never have to take my word for anything.
This started with a simple frustration.
I kept reading numbers about the parks that nobody could check. Prices with no source. Trends with no data behind them. So I started collecting the numbers myself and writing down exactly where each one came from.
Then I wrote down the rules I wished everyone publishing numbers would follow, and I hold every Starlane Report to them. Here they are.
The rules
1
Every number is dated. You can see when it was true.
2
Public sources only. Every source is listed and linked.
3
Deterministic where possible. The same input always produces the same number, with no manual rekeying and no estimation.
4
We respect robots rules and do not drive quote calculators.
5
Our own businesses get the same treatment as everyone else's, and our ownership is documented in the same public records.
6
Corrections are invited and land in the next snapshot, credited.
The Starlane Confidence Scale
Every sourced claim in a report wears a tier, so you always know what kind of evidence stands behind it.
Registry confirmed
Matched to a government or official registry record we retrieved ourselves.
Press reported
Reported by an independent outlet we link to.
Self reported
The company's own statements, filings it published, or its BBB profile.
Community reported
Sourced from forums or social threads, linked, treated as sentiment rather than fact.
Derived
Arithmetic on two figures the same operator published for the same stay, with the work shown beside the result.
A claim carries the tier of its weakest necessary source, and draft tiers are never published.
The tiers describe the kind of source, not a universal ranking. For what a company says its own policy is, the company's own document is the strongest source there is.
Defined here before they appear anywhere.
- The Broker's Cut
- What the middle takes in a DVC point rental: the renter price minus the owner payout on the same rental, per point. Where a company publishes its owner payout as a ceiling, the cut is a floor and is labelled one. The transparency score asks what a stranger can work out exactly; the Broker's Cut asks what the middle keeps at minimum, so a ceiling can feed the cut and still not count as firm. In the same way, the median owner payout reads "up to" when most of the cells behind it are ceilings, as the cut reads "at least".
- Transparency Score
- How much of a rental's money you can work out from a company's own public pages before you ask for a quote, from 0 to 100. Forty points for the renter price, forty for the owner payout, twenty for whether the two can be paired so the cut can be computed. Each part is the share of a fixed grid, the nineteen DVC resorts in two booking windows split at seven months, where the company states a firm figure. A rate card by resort, a flat rate card for every resort, and a live public listing tied to a resort all count as firm. A ceiling, a promotion, a calculator default or a fee earns a quarter of its part. Figures of the same kind that contradict each other on the same site earn nothing. A surcharge added to some bookings is not a price and is not scored. The score is computed from the dated readings in force for that company, so the same pages always produce the same score whatever another company publishes. It measures what is published. It does not measure price or service. Sleep Around Points is not scored, because the author owns it. The rule applies from the Q4 2026 edition; the Q3 2026 scores were editorial, and under this rule they read 63, 87, 50 and 10 instead of 100, 72, 24 and 7. The Q4 2026 edition reads 66, 95, 50 and 20, in the same order.
- Creator Score
- How a parks creator's published work holds up when it is checked: an editorial score from 0 to 100 built from source quality, correction behavior, and disclosure of paid relationships, measured against a dated snapshot of that creator's public output.
- Guest Score
- What the audience says about the same creator, scored separately from the work: a 0 to 100 reading of public sentiment in forums, comments, and social threads, sourced and linked, and treated as sentiment rather than fact.
New metrics get named and defined here before they appear in a report, and the definitions never move.
Rulings, dated.
When a page can be read two ways, the call is written down here with its date. Every reading follows it, earlier ones included, and no saved page is ever edited.
Live public listings count as firm prices for every company: on the renter side always, and on the owner side when the owner fee is exact.
The Transparency Score follows a written rule from the Q4 2026 edition. The Q3 2026 scores were editorial.
Every company is scored on the same fixed grid, the nineteen DVC resorts in two booking windows split at seven months, so a score never moves because another company priced a new resort.
A rate card that names no resort is a flat rate for every resort and covers the whole grid on its side.
Two figures contradict only when they are the same kind and name no resort, so a promotion beside a calculator default is two products, not a contradiction.
A figure that says up to is a ceiling and is never scored as a firm price, even when it names a resort.
A ceiling tied to a named resort earns half credit on its side, and a pair built on one counts at half weight in the take.
DVC Shop's owner figures say up to, so they are ceilings, not a rate card, in every lap.
An owner ceiling tied to a named resort pairs with the firm renter price, and the Broker's Cut it gives is a floor, shown as at least.
A company whose pages could not be read keeps the score from its last successful reading, labelled with that reading's date.
A figure is read from the text a reader sees, never from page metadata.
DVC Shop's added charge for small bookings is a surcharge, not a rate, and is not scored.
A sale price is the rate card, because it is what a renter pays today. The struck price is noted.
David's standard owner rate covers all resorts inside 7 months, read as the resorts in its own calculator, and its nine standard home resorts 7 to 11 months out.
David's Platinum renter rate covers only the resorts it names, not the Polynesian Island Tower.
A renter figure with no booking window pairs with an owner figure for the same resort in each window.
A company's sentence about what the market charges is commentary, not a reading.
A fee is keyed by what it is, standard or founding, so a fee that did not change reads as unchanged.
DVC Shop's and DVC Rental Store's confirmed-reservation boards are read from this date, so every company that publishes a board of live listings is counted.
A listing without a per-point price is counted but not priced.
A per-point figure derived from a company's own price and points is shown as derived, never scored, never a rate card.
Cadence, corrections, and reuse
Every report runs on a dated snapshot. Some topics get measured quarterly, others yearly, whatever the data honestly supports. The data date is stamped on every figure and every download, so you can always see exactly when a number was true.
If something here is wrong, tell me where you found the right answer. The fix lands in the next edition and you get credited for catching it.
Everything is released under CC BY 4.0. Use it, chart it, quote it. Cite Michael Starlane when you do. If you are citing this page, cite it as: Starlane, Michael. “The Starlane Method.” michaelstarlane.com.
Verification is owed to readers. Replication is not.
We publish what a reader needs to trust a number. We do not publish what a competitor needs to reproduce the pipeline.
The collection and synthesis systems behind Starlane Reports are proprietary. The parsers, weightings, prompts, and pipelines stay in house. The sources, definitions, and rules above do not. That split is deliberate: you should be able to check every number without us, and no one should be able to skip the work by copying ours.
The Going Rate applies this method on a regular schedule, with every figure dated and sourced.
Starlane Observatory™
Reports land here first. Free and open to everyone.